Losing a loved one is difficult under any circumstances, but when a dispute arises over their Will, the emotional burden can quickly become even more complicated. Whether due to misunderstandings, suspicions of unfairness or claims of legal invalidity, Will disputes are unfortunately not uncommon in the UK. When they do occur, they can lead to delays in the administration of the estate, financial strain and lasting rifts between family members. At Premier Solicitors, we regularly help clients navigate contentious probate matters, including disputes over the validity and fairness of Wills. If you are concerned about a Will, or if someone is challenging one where you are an executor or beneficiary, it is vital to understand the grounds for disputes, the legal process involved and how best to approach the situation.
There are several reasons why someone might challenge a Will. Most disputes fall into one of the following categories:
1. Questions Over the Will's Validity
A Will may be disputed if there is reason to believe it is not legally valid. In the UK, for a Will to be valid, it must be:
- Made by a person aged 18 or over
- Made voluntarily and without pressure
- Made by someone of sound mind who understands what they are doing
- Signed in the presence of two witnesses, who also sign the document
If any of these conditions were not met, the Will may be invalid. For example, if someone was suffering from dementia when the Will was signed, or if it was not properly witnessed, the Will may be contested.
2. Claims of Undue Influence
A person may dispute a Will if they believe the deceased was pressured or coerced into changing their wishes.
Proving undue influence can be difficult and usually requires strong evidence. It is not enough to show that someone persuaded the deceased; it must be shown that their free will was overridden.
3. Allegations of Fraud or Forgery
In rare but serious cases, a Will may be challenged on the basis that it has been forged or fraudulently altered. This may involve questioning the authenticity of the signature, the presence of suspicious amendments or evidence that someone tampered with the contents.
4. Disputes Over Lack of Provision
Even where a Will is valid, certain individuals may be entitled to make a claim if they believe they have not been properly provided for. Under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, a spouse, civil partner, child, cohabiting partner or other financial dependant can apply to the court for reasonable financial provision from the estate.
This is particularly common where someone is left out of the Will entirely, or where the distribution appears unfair given their circumstances.
5. Ambiguities or Errors in the Will
A Will may also be disputed if it contains unclear language, contradictions or drafting errors that make it difficult to interpret the testator's intentions. In such cases, the court may be asked to interpret or rectify the Will to reflect what the deceased intended.
Contesting a Will is a formal legal process. The first step is usually to raise a 'caveat' with the Probate Registry. This prevents the grant of probate from being issued and allows time for the dispute to be investigated and resolved. A caveat lasts for six months but can be extended if necessary.
Once a caveat is in place, the parties involved may attempt to resolve the dispute through negotiation or mediation.
In many cases, this can avoid the need for court proceedings. However, if no resolution is found, the matter may proceed to court, where a judge will decide whether the Will is valid and how the estate should be administered.
The court will consider all available evidence, including medical records, witness statements and expert opinions. The outcome will depend on the specific facts of the case, but may involve declaring the Will invalid, reinstating an earlier Will or altering the distribution of the estate to make reasonable financial provision.
In general, only individuals with a direct interest in the estate may contest a Will. This usually includes:
- Beneficiaries named in the Will
- Individuals who would benefit if the Will were declared invalid, such as next of kin under intestacy rules
- Dependants or others entitled to claim under the Inheritance Act
You must also act promptly. The time limits for contesting a Will vary depending on the nature of the claim.
For example, a claim under the Inheritance Act must usually be made within six months of the grant of probate. Other claims, such as those based on fraud, may not have a strict deadline but should still be brought as soon as possible.
Yes. If you are an executor and the Will is being contested, you are under a duty to remain neutral and act in the best interests of the estate. However, this does not mean doing nothing. You may need to provide information, documents or statements to assist in resolving the dispute.
In some cases, the beneficiaries may take on the role of defending the Will's validity, especially if they are the ones whose inheritance is at risk. If the dispute escalates to court, it is vital to seek legal advice to ensure your actions as executor are legally sound and to avoid being held personally liable for any losses to the estate.
While not all disputes can be prevented, there are steps that individuals can take to minimise the risk of their Will being challenged after their death.
These include:
- Ensuring the Will is drafted by a qualified solicitor
- Keeping the Will up to date, especially after major life changes
- Communicating intentions clearly to family members
- Including a detailed explanation for any decisions that may seem unusual or controversial
- Asking a solicitor to assess mental capacity at the time the Will is made, especially if the testator is elderly or unwell
Taking a clear and professional approach when making a Will can significantly reduce the likelihood of a successful challenge.
Disputes over a Will can be stressful, time-consuming and emotionally damaging. Whether you are concerned about the validity of a loved one's Will, or you are facing a challenge as an executor or beneficiary, it is essential to seek expert advice as early as possible.
At Premier Solicitors, our contentious probate team has extensive experience dealing with all aspects of Will disputes. We offer clear, practical advice and work to resolve disputes efficiently and with sensitivity to the circumstances. In many cases, early legal intervention can prevent a full-blown court battle and lead to a fair and timely resolution.
If you need help contesting a Will or defending one against a challenge, contact Premier Solicitors today. We are here to guide you through the process and protect your interests every step of the way.
For more information, please call us on 01234 358 080 or visit our contact page to send an enquiry form.
Read more blog posts which Mohsin has written for this website.
